Blended CAC is lying again
💸Why scaling spend can mean paying more for repeats, and more!
Hey Readers 🥰
Welcome to today’s edition, bringing the latest growth stories fresh to your inbox.
And just a quick heads-up! If you stumbled upon us through a friend, make sure to subscribe below! That way, you’ll never miss out on the trending stories.
💸 Blended CAC is lying again
If your account feels “healthy” at $20K spend but gets weird at $60K, it is rarely the algorithm. It is usually one quiet shift: you started paying more for the same people.
That is the hidden tax inside most scaling stories. Not CPM. Not creative fatigue.
The new customer tax, where spend grows faster than first-time buyers. Blended metrics hide it beautifully.
ROAS stays respectable because warm buyers keep converting. CPA looks stable because returning customers are cheaper to close. So teams scale, thinking they are building a bigger machine.
But they are often just squeezing the same sponge harder. nCAC fixes this because it asks a CFO question, not a media buyer question.
“How much did we pay to add a new customer to the business?”
Not to get a purchase. To get a person you did not already own.
Why nCAC changes how you scale
A media buyer can scale on blended CAC and claim victory. A CFO cannot, because blended CAC can be “profit today, starvation tomorrow.”
If your new customer intake slows while spend rises, your future revenue pipeline shrinks even as you celebrate.
That is how brands become addicted to retargeting. They keep the dashboard green while the top of the funnel quietly dries up. nCAC is the antidote because it forces the honest split:
new customers versus everyone else.
The nCAC playbook, kept sharp
1) Build the two-column view
Every campaign gets two outputs. New customers acquired. Returning customers acquired.
If you cannot see those as separate lines, you are not measuring growth, you are measuring motion.
2) Do the one calculation that matters
For each cold or prospecting-heavy campaign: nCAC = spend ÷ new customers. Do not average it across the account, because averages are where the truth goes to die.
3) Add one guardrail and stop negotiating with yourself
Pick an nCAC ceiling based on your economics. If your first-order margin cannot carry it, you need better pre-sell, better offer, or better creative.
If your 60 to 90 day LTV can carry it, you have permission to scale without flinching.
4) Track new customer mix like it is oxygen
Ask this weekly:
“What percent of spend produced first-time buyers?”
If that percentage drops for three weeks while spend rises, you are paying more for familiarity, not growth.
This is where Lindy AI CMO fits cleanly, because you can have agents create a reporting doc that breaks out new versus returning customers and highlights nCAC by campaign, with everything automatically organized in Airtable and ready to deploy. See AI Agents in Action today!
ROAS tells you how good you are at converting. nCAC tells you whether you are actually expanding the business. If you want real scale, treat new customers like inventory. Track the cost of acquiring them like a CFO.
Partnership with Insense
Turn One Creator Drop Into Weeks of Q5 Ads
This is the week where every ad starts dying at the same time, and teams scramble for anything new to ship. Doing nothing means pouring budget into creatives that stopped converting yesterday.
This is exactly where Insense saves you. You get fast, affordable UGC at the volume Q5 demands without blowing up your team’s bandwidth.
- 20+ raw assets from each creator you can spin into dozens of variations.
- 14-day turnaround so you never fall behind rising CPMs.
- Lifetime usage rights, so every winning cut keeps earning for months.
- Cost-efficient sourcing that lets you test aggressively
Over 2,000+ brands like Quip, Revolut, and Matys use Insense for one reason: it keeps creative supply high when everything else slows down.
Imagine finishing Q5 with a full folder of fresh ads ready to deploy instead of praying old winners magically revive.
Book a free strategy call by December 12th and get $200 for your first campaign!
🗝️ Tweet of the Day
Advertise with Us
70% of email clicks are bots but not with The Playbook. Reach real human buyers with verified clicks and only pay for actual engagement.
We'd love to hear your feedback on today's issue! Simply reply to this email and share your thoughts on how we can improve our content and format. 😍