You’re Not Scaling, You’re Looping

🔁 Why your “high-ROAS” Google campaign might just be expensive demand recycling

Playbook

31 Jul 2025 — 3 min read

Hey Readers 🥰

Welcome to today’s edition, bringing the latest growth stories fresh to your inbox.

And just a quick heads-up! If you stumbled upon us through a friend, make sure to subscribe below! That way, you’ll never miss out on the trending stories.

Subscribe now

🔁 Why your “high-ROAS” Google campaign might just be expensive demand recycling

Marketers love a good-looking dashboard. Especially when it flashes a 4x or 5x ROAS. But beneath that shiny number, many DTC brands are mistaking retention for acquisition, paying real dollars to win customers they already had.

Most ROAS Wins Are Just Google Catching the Pass

When 80–90% of conversions come from branded terms or near-matches, you’re not running performance marketing. You’re running a toll booth on your own audience. Google’s just catching the demand created elsewhere and charging you for it.

This shows up especially in Performance Max and broad match campaigns. Without exclusions, these suck in brand queries, repeat buyers, and loyalists, creating inflated ROAS with no net new growth.

Branded Terms Are Defense, Not Offense

You should run branded campaigns to block competitors and protect your SERP real estate. But you shouldn’t celebrate their ROAS like it’s an acquisition. The moment you include branded revenue in your Google ROAS, you blur the line between new demand and brand protection.

True growth shows up in non-brand search. It’s harder, more expensive, and lower ROAS at first, but that’s where scale lives.

Google Doesn’t Scale Cold Without Intent Mapping

Want to scale on Google? That starts with isolating real cold traffic:

Exclude branded and near-brand queries aggressively.
Break out non-brand campaigns into their own ROAS tracking.
Push into competitor, category, and solution-aware terms.

This forces you to track acquisition-driven performance, not recycled revenue.

What Smart DTC Teams Do Instead

They separate brand protection from cold prospecting budgets. They view branded search ROAS as a retention benchmark, not an acquisition metric. And they attribute real growth to cold platforms (Meta, TikTok) that create demand, not just capture it.

In this setup, Google becomes a closer, not the quarterback. The win happens earlier in the funnel, and ROAS becomes an efficiency lever, not a growth signal.

If you’re celebrating Google ROAS without dissecting the source, you’re probably just buying back your customers. The future of profitable scale in DTC lies in creating intent, not endlessly paying to intercept it.

Want better ROI? Stop looping. Start building cold pipelines that convert.

Partnership with Insense

Find your perfect influencers in 48 hours - who actually follow the brief!

UGC delivers 4× higher CTRs and 50% lower CPC than traditional ads.

But... trying to source & manage creators yourself is time-consuming.

You need Insense’s carefully vetted marketplace of 68,500+ UGC creators and micro-influencers from 35+ countries across the USA, Canada, Europe, APAC, and Latin America.

Major eComm brands are using Insense to find their perfect niche creators and run diverse end-to-end collaborations from product seeding and gifting to TikTok Shop and affiliate campaigns, and whitelisted ads.